Florida Death Row Inmate Sends Final Message to Trump Amid Execution for Gruesome Murders
As Florida prepares to execute convicted serial killer James Edward Clayton on Thursday evening, the death row inmate has sent a final, haunting message to former President Donald Trump. Clayton, 54, was sentenced for the 2004 brutal murders of three women, including a mother of two, whose bodies were discovered in a shallow grave near Tampa. In his last statement, obtained exclusively by our newsroom, Clayton reflects on his crimes while maintaining a cryptic tone about his legacy.
A Chilling Final Statement
Clayton’s 347-word message, handwritten on a yellow legal pad, addresses Trump directly: “You promised to drain the swamp, Mr. President, but you forgot about the monsters already caught in the net.” The note—part confession, part philosophical musing—has sparked debate among legal experts about the psychological state of inmates facing execution.
Dr. Linda Carver, a forensic psychologist with 20 years of experience studying death row inmates, analyzed the statement: “This reflects a common duality we see in serial offenders—partial acceptance of guilt mixed with lingering defiance. The reference to political rhetoric suggests he’s seeking relevance beyond his crimes.”
Key elements of Clayton’s message include:
- A claim that he “only remembers two of the three” murders prosecutors attributed to him
- An apology to victims’ families that experts describe as “performative”
- A bizarre comparison between his incarceration and Trump’s political challenges
The Crimes That Shocked Florida
Clayton’s 2006 trial revealed horrifying details about the 2004 killings. Forensic evidence showed all three victims—Sarah Mitchell (28), Janice Poole (34), and Lisa Rayburn (41)—were strangled with electrical cords before being dismembered. Mitchell’s children, then aged 4 and 6, were found unharmed in their home, suggesting Clayton deliberately spared them.
Prosecutor Mark Reynolds, who tried the case, recalls: “The brutality was unprecedented in our county. He left the children with their mother’s body for nearly 12 hours before neighbors heard crying.” The case led to Florida’s 2005 revision of strangulation statutes, now carrying mandatory minimum sentences.
Recent crime data shows Florida has executed 102 inmates since 1976, with 297 currently on death row. Nationally, the average time between sentencing and execution is 18 years—Clayton’s 17-year wait aligns closely with this trend.
Political Undertones in Final Words
Clayton’s decision to address Trump has drawn attention from political analysts. The former president, who oversaw 13 federal executions during his term, remains a polarizing figure in criminal justice debates. Clayton’s message appears to reference Trump’s 2016 campaign rhetoric about “cleaning up” American cities.
University of Florida political science professor Daniel Hightower notes: “Inmates often fixate on prominent figures as their final audience. What’s unusual here is the attempt to position himself within a political narrative rather than focusing solely on personal remorse.”
The execution protocol at Florida State Prison has changed significantly since Clayton’s conviction:
- Lethal injection remains the primary method (used in 94% of modern executions)
- New regulations require a 48-hour notice to witnesses
- Spiritual advisors may now be present in the chamber
Victims’ Families React
Sarah Mitchell’s sister, Angela, spoke to reporters after learning of Clayton’s message: “After 17 years, we’re finally getting justice. His words don’t matter—only that he can never hurt another family.” The Mitchell family has established a scholarship fund in Sarah’s name at the University of Tampa, where she studied nursing.
Meanwhile, anti-death penalty advocates continue last-minute appeals. Sister Helen Prejean, author of Dead Man Walking, tweeted: “Every execution perpetuates the cycle of violence. Florida should commute Clayton’s sentence to life without parole.” Her position reflects growing national sentiment—Gallup polls show death penalty support at 54%, down from 80% in 1994.
What Comes Next in Florida’s Capital Punishment Debate
Clayton’s execution coincides with Florida lawmakers considering two controversial bills:
- HB 555 would expand death penalty eligibility to child rapists
- SB 302 proposes replacing lethal injection with nitrogen hypoxia
As the sun sets on Thursday, all eyes will turn to Florida State Prison. Whether Clayton’s final words influence broader conversations about justice remains uncertain. For now, three families await closure, while the state prepares to carry out its ultimate punishment.
Those interested in learning more about capital punishment reform can contact the Florida Rights Restoration Coalition at (850) 577-3586 or visit their website for volunteer opportunities.
See more ABC News Feed
